Connect with us


Indians Lose 5-3 to the Yankees

The start of the second game of the series had an eerie feel of Déjà Vu. The Tribe scored three in the first inning but after that their bats fell silent. The Yankees came into Cleveland last in the American League. Their offense was struggling but has found life at Progressive Field. The Bronx bombers hit four out of the park tonight.

Logan Allen pitched only 2.1 innings giving up five hits and four earned runs. Skipper Terry Francona used several relievers: Phil Maton, Trevor Stephan, and Cal Quantrill to help keep the Indians in the game. The bullpen did their job, but the lumber couldn’t heat up.

Jordan Montgomery was able to settle down after the first inning and find a rhythm. The Tribe went one for nine with runners in scoring position the rest of the game. Montgomery pitched a little over four innings and was visibly upset to leave the hill.

With a good start to the game the wind was taken out of the sails of the Tribe’s sinking ship. The lack of offense is like a record on repeat. Yes, the season is still early but it is discouraging that the team is unable to bring runners home game after game.

Fans have pointed fingers calling for players with low batting averages to be sent down. They have also questioned Tito’s lineup and positioning of players in the field. Tonight, none of those situations were the issue. In fact, the reality is that this team is simply not finding a way to win.

What will it take for this team to gel? Who will step up offensively and get the rally going? The talent is there but what is lacking? These are questions that swirl around the clubhouse and amongst fans. Sometimes it just takes a team the ability to string a few wins together to gain confidence.


I attended Malone College to pursue a Journalism career in Politics...I have found that writing about Sports is a lot more fun! I am an avid NBA, MLB & NFL fan. Find me on Twitter @nats_sportschat



  1. Michael R. Harris

    April 24, 2021 at 9:00 am

    I really enjoy your takes on the Indians. I probably disagree on a lot, but I love reading them.

  2. Bill

    April 24, 2021 at 9:55 am

    The past few years, the Indians were structured to beat the bad teams; play even with the good teams; and, win some against the top teams. Now, they are no better than a .500 team. We’ll have to get used to it as their fortunes go down.

  3. Randy

    April 24, 2021 at 2:18 pm

    I have seen enough of Jake Bauers. He is not the only problem but is one of them. He has never hit in his major league life. If another team wants to claim him, (I doubt it) then let them. Certainly there has to be someone in Columbus who can play a decent first base and hit better but if not Josh Naylor has spent the majority of his career time as a first baseman. The backup catcher, even though he only sees game action once a week, may be a great handler of pitchers but probably hits as badly as I would if I were he.I like Rosario in center and let Luplow play right with Naylor at first. It couldn’t get any worse.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.





Show Your Team Spirit

NEO Sports Insiders Newsletter

Sign up to receive our NEOSI newsletter, and keep up to date with all the latest Cleveland sports news.

Recent Comments


More in Indians