Connect with us


Cleveland Browns First Half Report Card

all-time browns

Cleveland, OH-

Welp. Here we are. The halfway point of the season. The Cleveland Browns are 3-5. How are we feeling Browns fans? Looking back at the last two months, the Browns have been up and down. The NFL season is so incredibly long. It seems like a year ago, the Browns played a must win in the first game of the season. All the way back in week 2, the Browns gave up a 13-point lead in the final 1:55. That was 2 months ago. In the time since, there have been injuries, which were expected, a Myles Garrett car accident, trade rumors, coaching change rumors… I mean, the Browns have had a season’s worth of story lines in the first half of the season.



I know that is a pretty high grade for a team with 3 wins. Here’s my thinking. The Browns are averaging 25 ppg. That is good enough for the 6th best in the league. The offense with Jacoby Brissett is playing well. Nick Chubb is leading the league in rushing yards with 841 yards and 10 touchdowns. Amari Cooper is looking like a WR1 again and has had some dominant games. David Njoku has broken out as a reliable TE. Even Donovan People-Jones has been very steady.

The offensive line has been good. Ethan Pocic has looked like a really good find at the center position. The offense for the most part has done their job. They have kept the Browns in games. The only game they weren’t good in, was New England, and you expect to have clunkers. Brissett through the first 8 weeks is top 10 in passing yards. Like, you really can’t ask for much more from this unit. They have really surprised.



Here is where things get a bit tricky. The defense has been bad. The defense has been good. Through eight weeks, you just don’t know which defense is going to show up. Is it going to be the defense that held the Ravens to 23 points? Or the defense that gave up 31 to Joe Flacco and the Jets? The defense that allowed only eight passes to be completed by the Falcons? Or the defense that allowed 200 yards rushing to the Chargers?

The problem is, until the Monday Night win over the Bengals, the Browns defense had yet to put a full game complete defensive game together. There was always SOMETHING happening. In the first game you needed a 58-yard game winning FG from Cade York because the defense gave up late touchdowns. The next game was the Jets debacle where the defense lost the game in the last 1:55.

The Browns defense has talent. Really, they do. But they are in a situation where they are underperforming. Joe Woods is on the hot seat. His defense has been all over the place. One week the DB’S play well but can’t stop the run. Next week, the run is stopped, but they get shredded through the air. This is a unit that said they had top five ambitions. They aren’t even close right now.

Now, to be fair, there have been injuries on this side of the ball. Myles Garrett had the accident causing him to miss the Atlanta game. Jadeveon Clowney was dealing with the ankle injury. Denzel Ward is dealing with a concussion. These are three of your best players on defense that are missing games. Three of the best players at their positions. Naturally there will be some drop off. Anthony Walker suffered a season ending injury. These things happen. This is the nature of the game.

There have been some pleasant surprises. Isaiah Thomas has been a pretty good back up and shown some flashes. As has Alex Wright. They are young players though. They are working through mistakes. Learning. We need them in the second half to learn faster. The Browns traded for Deon Jones. In his first game, there was a noticeable difference in the run defense. Pairing him with Sione Takitaki and Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah should have the linebackers be able to make more plays in the run game. I want to be clear. This unit has talent. They can be good. But so far, this has been the most disappointing unit on the team.



I know giving a C is a high-grade considering the team is 3-5. The thinking is, even with the record, the Browns have been in every single game except the New England game. Out of the five losses, they could have just as easily won three (Jets, Falcons, Chargers) and possibly a fourth in the Ravens. Despite all that has gone on, the Browns are not out of it.

The second half starts a lot tougher with games against Miami, Buffalo, and Tampa Bay. However, if the Browns can win two of those games, they do have hope. They will get Deshaun Watson back week 13, and while he hasn’t played in two years, the last time he did play, he was a top 10 QB. All is not lost. There is a path where this season can turn around and the Browns can win the division. But it starts now.

If the Browns can figure things out defensively, and keep doing what they are doing on offense, this team can be really dangerous come playoff time. The Browns have to learn how to win though. They have to learn how to win the close games, and they have to learn how to keep their foot on other team’s necks. There are nine games left. Winning five of the remaining games will not be enough. The Browns need to win at least six games to have a chance at the playoffs. The schedule opens up, so it is possible. Let’s see if they can finish the year with an A grade.





  1. Robert

    November 4, 2022 at 3:43 pm

    You didn’t rate one of the most important factors: coaching. My grade for Stefanski, especially, and his assistants, is F.

  2. C biggsy

    November 4, 2022 at 9:37 pm

    The secondary looked its best w/o Ward in the win over Cincy.

  3. Keith Goodmab

    November 5, 2022 at 8:25 am

    The grades are too high. The RBs are an A+ however nit used enough. The WR a B. Amari Cooper an A and the rest a B. The QB is a C+. On one hand he has played some real good games. On the other hand he can’t close games. He has had interceptions at crucial times. TD to INT numbers are mediocre at best. On the other hand, he has done an adequate job as a backup and very durable. The Special teams ranking is a D+. Cade York has a great leg but the line has been off. I think this will improve, but the ST coaching has been awful. Let’s not forget the only onside kick recovered by an offense. Overall coaching is a D-. The obvious good part is the offense as a whole. The bad parts with the exception of the Cincy game for the defense and 2 games for the special teams. Otherwise the defense is an D-. They play decent and then might as well not be on the field with 5 min to go. The only encouraging thing is the Cincy game was much improved. Of course Cincy has a terrible OL and Chase was out. Overall I give the club a C-

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *





Show Your Team Spirit

NEO Sports Insiders Newsletter

Sign up to receive our NEOSI newsletter, and keep up to date with all the latest Cleveland sports news.

Recent Comments


More in Browns